Knowledge / Glossary
Competitive Alternatives
What customers would do if your product did not exist, including competitors, workarounds and doing nothing.
1 min readUpdated 2026-11-15By Meridian Academy
What customers would do if your product did not exist, including competitors, workarounds and doing nothing.
Summary
Your real competitor is often the workaround, not the brand you watch.
What Is Competitive Alternatives?
Competitive alternatives are all the options customers compare you with. They include direct competitors, different types of solutions, manual workarounds, hiring someone and simply doing nothing. Understanding them is the first step in positioning, since your value is defined relative to the alternatives.
People may also refer to this concept as:
- 1.Alternatives
- 2.Competitive set
Purpose and Context
Why It Matters
Companies often compare themselves with the wrong rivals. Knowing the real alternatives shows what is truly unique and why customers switch.
Key Elements
| Element | What it means |
|---|---|
| Direct competitors | similar products |
| Indirect alternatives | different solutions |
| Workarounds | spreadsheets, manual work |
| Status quo | doing nothing |
| Switching triggers | why people move |
How It Works
- 1.Ask customers
- 2.List all alternatives
- 3.Compare
- 4.Position
Ask customers
What would you use if we did not exist?
List all alternatives
Include workarounds and doing nothing.
Compare
Note where you are better or worse.
Position
Highlight the strengths that matter against the real alternatives.
Examples
Competing with spreadsheets
Competing with spreadsheets
A project tool compared itself with other project tools and struggled.
What they did
- 1.Customer interviews showed most switched from spreadsheets
- 2.Rewrote messaging around what spreadsheets cannot do, like automatic reminders and permissions
- 3.Offered spreadsheet import
What happened
Trial conversion improved 28%.
Comparisons and Boundaries
| Related term | Relationship | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|
| Positioning | Builds on | Positioning starts with alternatives |
| Competitive Analysis | Used with | Analysis studies alternatives |
| Status Quo Bias | Used with | Status quo is a strong alternative |
| Jobs to Be Done | Used with | Jobs reveal unexpected alternatives |
Common Misconceptions
| Mistake | What to do instead |
|---|---|
| Ignoring do nothing | Inaction is often the biggest competitor. |
| Listing only famous rivals | Ask customers what they actually compare. |
Related concepts
Sources
- [1] April Dunford, Obviously Awesome
- [2] Allan Dib, The 1-Page Marketing Plan
- [3] Al Ries and Jack Trout, Positioning: The Battle for Your Mind